Personalized & Heartfelt
Under $25
Find thoughtful personalized gifts under $25 that never feel like a budget buy. Shop custom mugs, engraved keychains, photo golf balls, wooden plaques, and more affordable made-to-order keepsakes — perfect for stocking stuffers, party favors, and last-minute gifting.
✦ Free Personalization Included
·
✦ Handmade to Order
·
✦ Happiness Guaranteed
Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament - Teddy Bear & Gift Ribbon Ceramic
$20.00
Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament - Rocking Horse
$20.00
Personalized Baby's First Christmas Ornament - Teddy Bear & Tree
$14.12
Personalized Halloween Fabric Candy Basket
$20.00
Puffin Lime Gift Card
$10.00
Baby's First Christmas Ceramic Photo Ornament | Theater Stage Frame | Custom Name & Year
$20.00
Custom Baby First Christmas Ornament with Name & Year
$20.00
Personalized Dog Collar with Letter Charms – Custom Waterproof Silicone Collar & Leash Set
$18.90
Personalized Slow Feeder Dog Bowl
$20.00
Personalized family bear Wood Christmas ornament
$20.00
My First Halloween Baby Ornament | Ceramic Personalized Keepsake
$24.43
My First Halloween 2026 Ceramic Ornament | Baby Name Personalized
$24.43
Personalized My First Halloween 2026 Ceramic Ornament | Baby Halloween Keepsake
$24.43
My First Halloween 2026 baby clothes line Ornament | Ceramic Name Personalized
$24.43
My First Halloween 2026 Photo Ornament Ceramic Decoration
$24.43
Personalized My First Halloween Ornament | Ceramic Keepsake 2026
$24.43
Personalized My First Halloween Photo Ornament | Ceramic Ornament
$24.43
My First Halloween 2026 Baby Clothes Line Ceramic Ornament | Personalized Name
$24.43
Personalized Candy Monster Halloween Treat Bag
$24.99
Personalized Ghost, Black Cat & Pumpkin Kids Activity & Coloring Book
$22.44
Personalized Cute Spider Halloween Treat Bag
$24.99
Personalized Patchwork Halloween Treat Bag
$24.99
Personalized Little Skeleton Halloween Treat Bag
$24.99
Personalized Midnight Stars Halloween Treat Bag
$24.99
Personalized in Three Steps
01
Choose Your Gift
Browse keepsakes ready for your personal touch.
02
Add Your Details
Share a photo, a name, or a few special words.
03
We Create It
Lovingly made by hand and sent straight to you.
About Under $25
Find thoughtful personalized gifts under $25 that never feel like a budget buy. Shop custom mugs, engraved keychains, photo golf balls, wooden plaques, and more affordable made-to-order keepsakes — perfect for stocking stuffers, party favors, and last-minute gifting.